| Bhagavad-gétä 2.4-5 -- London, August 5, 1973
Pradyumna (leads chanting, etc.): arjuna uväca gurün ahatvä hi mahänubhävän Translation: "Arjuna said: O killer of Madhu (Kåñëa), how can I counterattack with arrows in battle men like Bhéñma and Droëa, who are worthy of my worship? It is better to live in this world by begging than to live at the cost of the lives of great souls who are my teachers. Even though they are avaricious, they are nonetheless superiors. If they are killed, our spoils will be tainted with blood." Prabhupäda: So the first problem was for Arjuna how to kill the kinsmen, family men. Now, when he was chastised by Kåñëa as a friend that "Why you are so weak? Dont be weak. This is sentiment. This kind of compassion is sentiment. Uttiñöha. You better get up and fight." If I do not want to do something, I can offer so many pleas. You see. So next he is presenting gurün: "All right, Kåñëa, you are talking about my kinsmen. I accept that it is my weakness. But how do You advise me to kill my guru? Droëäcärya is my guru. And Bhéñmadeva is also my guru. So do you want me to kill my guru? Gurün hi hatvä. And not only ordinary guru. This is not that they are ordinary men. Mahänubhävän. Bhéñma is a great devotee, and similarly, Droëäcärya also, a great personality. Mahänubhävän. So kathaà bhéñmam ahaà saìkhye droëaà ca madhusüdana. "They are two great personalities. They are not only my gurus, but they are great personalities." And Kåñëa is addressed "Madhusüdana." Madhusüdana means... Madhu was Kåñëas enemy, a demon. So He killed. So "You are Madhusüdana, You are killer of Your enemies. Can You give me any evidence that You have killed Your guru? So why You are asking me?" This is the purport. Iñubhiù pratiyotsyämi püjärhäv ari-südana. Again Ari-südana. Ari means enemy. Madhusüdana, particularly "the killer of the Madhu demon." And next is Arisudana. Ari means enemy. So Kåñëa has killed so many demons, ari, who came to fight with Him as enemy. Therefore His name is Arisudana. So Kåñëa has got enemies also, what to speak of ourself. This material world is so made, that you must have some enemies. Matsaratä. Matsaratä means enviousness, jealousy. This material world is like that. So there are jealous enemies of God also. They are called demons. Ordinary jealousy or enemy, that is natural. But even to God. Just like yesterday night, evening, somebody came to see me. He was arguing that "Why Kåñëa should be accepted as God?" That was his argument. So Kåñëa has enemies. Therefore Kåñëa... Not only He, but everyone who is in the material world is enemy of Kåñëa. Everyone. Because they want to be competitor of Kåñëa. Kåñëa says that bhoktäram: "I am the supreme enjoyer." Sarva-loka-maheçvaram: "I am the Supreme proprietor." And the Vedas also confirm, éçäväsyam idaà sarvam. "Everything is the property of the Supreme Lord." Sarvaà khalv idaà brahma. These are Vedic injunctions. Yato vä imäni bhütäni jäyante: "From whom everything has come." Janmädy asya yataù [SB 1.1.1]. These are Vedic versions. But still, we, because we are enemies, "No, why Kåñëa shall be the proprietor? I am the proprietor. Why Kåñëa shall be God only. I have got another God. Here is another God." So Kåñëa has enemies. Arisudana. And He has to kill them. Kåñëa has got two businesses: pariträëäya sädhünäà vinäçäya ca duñkåtam [Bg. 4.8]. Miscreants... They are miscreants. The demons who challenge Kåñëa, who want to compete with Kåñëa, who want to share with the property of Kåñëa, they are all enemies of Kåñëa, and they should be killed. So killing business is all right here for the enemies, not ordinarily. Then the next question is, "All right, enemies, you can kill, admitted But how you advise me to kill my gurus? Gurün ahatvä. But if for Kåñëas sake, if there is need, you have to kill your guru also. That is the philosophy. For Kåñëas sake. If Kåñëa wants, then you cannot... If Kåñëa wants that you should kill your guru, then you have to do it. That is Kåñëa consciousness. Of course, Kåñëa will not ask you to kill guru, but... Because guru and Kåñëa are the same. Guru-kåñëa-kåpäya. We get Kåñëa consciousness through the mercy of guru and Kåñëa. So real guru is never to be killed, but the so-called guru has to be killed. The so-called, pseudo guru, false guru, he should be killed. Just like Prahläda Mahäräja. While Prahläda Mahäräja... He was standing. Here is, Nåsiàhadeva is killing his father. Father is guru. Sarva-devamayo guruù. Similarly, father is also guru, at least, official guru. Materially he is guru. So how Prahläda Mahäräja allowed Nåsiàhadeva to kill his guru? Hes father. Everyone knows that Hiraëyakaçipu is father. Would you like to see that your father is being killed by some person and youll stand? You will not protest? Is that your duty? No, that is not your duty. When your father is attacked, you must protest. At least, if you are unable, you must fight. You first of all lay down your life: "How is that, my father is being killed in my front?" That is our duty. But Prahläda Mahäräja did not protest. He could have requestedhe is devotee"My dear sir, Prabhu, my Lord, You can excuse my father." He didnt. But he knew that "My father is not being killed. It is the body of the father." Later on he begged for his father in a different way. First of all, when Nåsiàhadeva was angry, He was killing the body, he knew that "The body is not my father. The soul is my father. So let the Lord satisfy Himself by killing the body of my father; then I shall save him." So Prahläda Mahäräja... Nåsiàhadeva offered Prahläda Mahäräja, "Now you can take any kind of benediction you like." So Prahläda Mahäräja replied, "My Lord, we are materialists. I am born of a father absolutely materialist. So I am also, because I am born of a materialist father, I am also materialist. And You, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are offering to give me some benediction. I can take any kind of benediction from You. I know that. But what is the use of it? Why shall I ask You for any benediction? I have seen my father. Materially, he was so powerful that even the demigods, Indra, Candra, Varuëa, they were threatened by his red eyes. And he gained over, control over the universe. He was so powerful. And riches, wealth, power, reputation, everything complete, but You have finished it in one second. So why You are offering me such benediction? What shall I do with them? If I take that benediction from You and I become puffed up and do everything wrong against You, then You can finish it within a second. So kindly do not offer me such benediction, such material opulence. Better give me benediction to be engaged in the service of Your servant. I want this benediction. Let me be benedicted by You that I may be engaged in the service of Your servant, not directly Your servant." Then, after many prayers, after pacifying the Lord... He was very angry. Then when He was little pacified, he asked, "My dear Lord, I can ask You one, another benediction. that my father was very, very staunch enemy of You. That was the cause of his death. Now I ask You kindly excuse him and give him liberation." This is Vaiñëava son. He did not ask anything for himself. And although he knew that his father was the greatest enemy, still, he is asking his benediction, "This poor fellow may be liberated." So Lord Nåsiàhadeva guaranteed, said, "My dear Prahläda, not only your father, but your fathers father, his father, up to fourteen generations, all are liberated. Because you are born in this family." So anyone who has become a Vaiñëava, a devotee of the Lord, he is giving the greatest service to the family. Because in relationship with him, his father, mother, anyone, they will be liberated. Just like we have got experience, if a person dies in the fight immaturely, his family is taken care of by the government. Similarly, to become a devotee is the greatest qualification. He has got everything. Yatra yogeçvaro hariù yatra dhanur-dharaù pärthaù. When there is Kåñëa and when there is devotee, all victory, all glories are there. That is guaranteed. So gurün ahatvä. A devotee of Kåñëa, if need be, if hes unqualified guru... Unqualified guru means who does not know how to guide the disciple. Gurus duty is to guide. So such kind of guru can be at least rejected. That is Jéva Gosvämés... Kärya-käryam ajänataù. A guru who does not know what to do and what not to do, but by mistake, by mistakenly I have accepted somebody as guru, he can be rejected. By rejecting him, you can accept an actual bona fide guru. So guru is not killed, but he can be rejected. That is the injunction of the çästra. So Bhéñmadeva or Droëäcärya, certainly they were gurus, but Kåñëa indirectly giving indication to Arjuna, that "Although they are in the position of guru, you can reject them." Kärya-käryam ajänataù. "They do not know factually." This Bhéñmadeva, he materially considered his position. He knew everything from the beginning, that the Päëòavas, they were parentless, fatherless children, and he raised them from the very beginning. Not only that, he was so much affectionate to the Päëòavas that he was thinking, when they were sent to forest, banished, at that time Bhéñmadeva was crying, that "These five boys, they are so pure, so honest, and not only pure and honest, so powerful warriors, Arjuna and Bhéma. And this Draupadé is practically directly the goddess of fortune. And they have got their friend, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. And they are suffering?" He cried. He was such affectionate. Therefore Arjuna is considering, "How can I kill Bhéñma?" But duty is so strong. Kåñëa is advising, "Yes, he must be killed because he has gone to the other side. He has forgotten his duty. He should have joined you. Therefore he is no more in the position of guru. You must kill him. He has wrongly joined the other party. Therefore there is no harm, killing him. Similarly Droëäcärya. Similarly Droëäcärya. I know they are great personalities, they have got great affection. But only on material consideration they have gone there." What is that material consideration? Bhéñma thought that "I am maintained by the money of Duryodhana. Duryodhana is maintaining me. Now he is in danger. If I go to the other side, then I should be ungrateful. He has maintained me so long. And if I, in the time of danger, when there is fighting, if I go to the other side, that will be..." He thought like this. He did not think that "Duryodhana may be maintaining, but he has usurped the property of the Päëòavas." But it is his greatness. He knew that Arjuna will never be killed because Kåñëa is there. "So from material point of view, I must be grateful to Duryodhana." The same position was for Droëäcärya. They were maintained. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu has said that viñayéra anna khäile maléna haya mana. Such great personalities became darkened because they took money from them, anna. If I am provided by somebody who is too much materialist, then that will affect me. I will become also materialist. I will also become materialist. So Caitanya Mahäprabhu has warned that "Those who are viñayé, those who are not devotees, do not accept anything from them because it will make your mind unclean." So therefore a brähmaëa and a Vaiñëava, they do not accept directly money. They accept bhikñä. Bhikñä. Just like here it is said bhaikñyam. Çreyo bhoktuà bhaikñyam apéha loke. When you ask somebody... Still, bhikñä is also sometimes prohibited from a person who is too much materialist. But bhikñä is allowed for sannyäsés, for brähmaëa. So therefore Arjuna is speaking that "Instead of killing such great gurus who are so great personalities, mahänubhävän..." So bhaikñyam. For a kñatriya... A brähmaëa, a sannyäsé can beg, can beg alms, but not a kñatriya, not a vaiçya. That is not allowed. So he was a kñatriya, Arjuna. So he says, "Better I shall take the profession of a brähmaëa and beg from door to door instead of enjoy the kingdom by killing my guru." That was his proposal. So on the whole, Arjuna is illusionedillusioned in the sense that he is forgetting his duty. He is a kñatriya, his duty is to fight; never mind the opposite party, even he is son, a kñatriya will not hesitate to kill his son even if he is inimical. Similarly, the son, if the father is inimical, he would not hesitate to kill his father. This is the stringent duty of the kñatriyas, no consideration. A kñatriya cannot consider like that. Therefore Kåñëa said, klaibyam: "You dont be coward. Why you are becoming coward?" These topics are going on. Later on, Kåñëa will give him real spiritual instruction. This is... Ordinary talks are going on between the friend and the friend. Thats all right. Thank you. (end) |